2025 AFC South Betting Preview: Top Picks, Smart Predictions & Season Outlook

The AFC South division is shaping up to be one of the most uncertain yet potentially profitable betting landscapes in the 2025 NFL season.

With franchise overhauls, quarterback experiments, and high-stakes coaching changes, every team presents a unique case.

Here’s a comprehensive betting breakdown, rooted entirely in the data and insights from a deep dive video analysis.

Houston Texans: Undervalued Contenders

The Houston Texans are lined at 9.5 wins with the over at even money and under at -120. Coming off a 10-7 season, this team has exceeded expectations under coach DeMeco Ryans.

While their offense averaged just 5.2 yards per play (below average), they boasted the fourth-best defense in the NFL in yards per play allowed (5.1).

Concerns around the offensive line persist after trading away Laremy Tunsil and replacing him with aging veterans.

Similarly, the receiver room is shaky with Stefon Diggs gone and Tank Dell likely sidelined. However, Christian Kirk and rookies from Iowa State offer potential.

Defensively, they feature top-end talent like Will Anderson, Danielle Hunter, and CB duo Derek Stingley and C.J. Gardner-Johnson.

Best Pick: Lean under 9.5 due to offensive line concerns and a brutal out-of-division schedule including Tampa Bay, Baltimore, and Buffalo.

Indianapolis Colts: Hot Seat Pressure

The Colts’ win total is 7.5, matching the Jaguars but with less favorable division odds. Coach Shane Steichen enters his third year with the urgency amplified by the owner’s death and management turnover. Despite playing the third-easiest schedule last year, they still finished 8-9.

Key indicators include a weak defense (ranked 24th in scoring, 29th in total defense) and turnover-prone QB play. The team signed Daniel Jones to compete with Anthony Richardson, signaling uncertainty at the position. Though the WR trio (Pittman, Downs, Pierce) is solid, offensive line depth and consistency remain major concerns.

Best Pick: Avoid at current number. Team volatility could offer in-season betting value.

Jacksonville Jaguars: Rebuild on the Fly

Despite their 7.5 win total, the Jaguars have better division odds than the Colts. Under new GM James Gladstone and rookie head coach Liam Cohen, Jacksonville is going through massive changes. The OC and DC are also first-timers, raising red flags.

Trevor Lawrence returns with four new offensive linemen, but the team ranked 31st in yards per play allowed last year (5.9). The receiving corps is young and promising but lacks proven depth. Jacksonville went 2-9 in one-score games last year and finished 4-13 overall despite a league-average schedule.

Best Pick: Slight under lean due to complete regime change and poor defensive metrics.

Tennessee Titans: Basement Watch

The Titans’ win total is set at 5.5 (over -150), with division and Super Bowl odds at longshot levels. After a 3-14 season and just two covers against the spread, optimism is low. Despite upgrading the offensive line with first-rounders and veterans, their receiving corps and defense remain severely lacking.

QB Cam Ward, a raw rookie, leads the offense behind a reshuffled but unproven line. The Titans were bottom-tier in special teams, skill talent, and pass rush in 2024. Even their free-agent additions look like overpays due to the lack of competitive allure.

Best Pick: Strong under lean. Titans are among the NFL’s weakest rosters, lacking talent and national relevance.

AFC South Betting Strategy Recap

• Strength of Schedule: All teams face AFC West and NFC West opponents. Houston’s extra games (TB, BAL, BUF) are brutal; Tennessee’s (NE, CLE, NO) easier but come late in the season.
• Watch for Late-Season Surges: Jaguars close with Tennessee, Indy, Jets, Denver—possible late value play.
• Fade National TV Bias: Titans have zero national games; Jaguars have only one—low public visibility may mean sharper lines.

AFC South Final Prediction Picks

1. Texans – Lean Under 9.5 Wins
2. Colts – Stay Away, Monitor In-Season Trends
3. Jaguars – Lean Under 7.5 Wins
4. Titans – Strong Under 5.5 Wins

Interested in More NFL Divisional Previews? Click Below!

2025 NFL Rule Changes

• Touchbacks on a kickoff will now give the receiving team the ball on the 35-yard line instead of the 30 in an effort to increase more kick returns and discourage touchbacks.
• The regular season overtime rules will now match the postseason overtime rules, as both teams will now have an opportunity to possess the ball regardless of the outcome of the first drive. Per Jon Ferrari of the Eagles, 37.5-percent of last year’s overtime games ended with a first-drive touchdown. The new rule will allow both teams to have the ball.
• The video review booth will have an increased role in assisting the on-field officials. The video assistants can’t put a flag on the field if they believe that the officials missed a call, but they can pick one up if an erroneous flag is thrown (i.e. a facemask penalty is called, but upon video review, it’s determined that the facemask was never actually grabbed).
• Artificial intelligence and lasers will be used to determine the remaining yardage for a first down. The officials are still responsible for spotting the football just like they always have, but technology will now do the job of the chain gang and they will no longer have to run in from the sidelines for a first down measurement. Once the official places the ball down, lasers will determine if the offense reached the first down line and/or how far away they are from reaching that mark.
• Teams that are trailing will now be able to attempt an onside kick at any point in the game from the 34-yard-line (instead of the traditional kickoff spot at the 35-yard-line). Previously, teams were only able to attempt an onside kick in the fourth quarter.

2025 Football GoldSheet Early Bird Special

Subscribe to the country’s longest-running sports betting newsletter for less than $7 per week. The Football GoldSheet will be your betting concierge through the 2025-26 football season, offering weekly NFL and NCAAF game previews, stat logs and much more. Early-bird subscribers will begin receiving preseason content in May as we recap the NFL draft and schedule release, plus season win totals and division previews.

WagerTalk Live Odds Screen

WagerTalk’s live odds screen features up-to-the-minute lines from a variety of offshore and domestic sports books. Track the moneylines, point spreads, totals and betting percentages for all AFC South games from their release in May all the way through Week 1 in September. Find free NFL picks from season win total bets through Super Bowl futures on our free picks pages.

**************************************************

Looking for more free sports picks and sports betting tips? Go beyond the anytime touchdown scorer picks!

• Latest Betting Odds and Public Action: Vegas lines updated in real time, including who the public is betting on and anytime touchdown scorer odds.
• Last Minute Handicapping Advice: Check out our extensive library of handicapping tips and advice from professional Vegas handicappers (we also recommend taking the time to look over our sports betting tips video library)
• Want an expert opinion? Check out the latest Free Sports Picks and Best Bets from our team of expert sports handicappers.

Make sure to bookmark all the above!