Best Home Run Prop Bets Today – HR Prop Picks For Tuesday, September 23

The 2025 MLB season is here, and who doesn’t love home run prop bets? Tons of home runs have already been hit this season and we’re ready to pick more winners in 2025! Free home run prop picks each day come at you compliments of WagerTalk.

We cashed our home run prop on Monday with Rafael Devers at +390! Let’s see if we can beat the books with home run prop bets on Tuesday! You can find free MLB picks every day at WagerTalk! Here are the best home run prop bets to make for Tuesday, September 23!

Best Home Run Prop Bets – MLB Free HR Props Picks

Spencer Steer (CIN) +480

The Reds look for their sixth straight win today in their hunt for a NL Wildcard berth hosting the Pirates. Pittsburgh sends righty Johan Oviedo to the mound tonight posting solid splits overall in minimum time this season.

He posts a 3.45 ERA across his last three starts but gave up two home runs in his last against the Cubs. We’ll look for Spencer Steer to hit his home run prop tonight sitting two home runs short of tying his career high for a season.

Steer has caught fire as of late batting .314 and slugging .686 so far in September which includes four total home runs in his last five games played.

Overall Steer has been a better hitter at home this season hitting 13 of his 21 home runs at the Great American Ballpark while batting .260 compared to batting just .222 on the road.

Ovideo has had most damage done to him by right handed hitters this season allowing a .241 batting average and .389 slugging percentage to righties compared to lefties allowing a .140 average and .281 slugging percentage.

Look for Steer to hit his home run prop tonight with odds listed at +480 with other Reds to consider for a home run prop includes Will Benson (+300) and Elly De La Cruz (+430).

MLB HR Props Best Bet of the Day #2: Rowdy Tellez (TEX) +350

Zebby Matthews has been disastrous as of late allowing a 9.88 ERA including two home runs combined in his last three starts as he takes the mound in Texas taking on the Rangers tonight.

Speaking of disasters, the Rangers are riding a seven-game losing streak and now sit five games back of the AL Wildcard making every game the rest of the way essentially a must-win.

We’re going to take a crack at lefty Rowdy Tellez to hit his home run prop tonight after hitting one last Friday at home against the Marlins.

Overall on the season Matthews’ road ERA sits at 6.23 while allowing seven of his 11 home runs in 39 IP. His struggles against lefties have been known as well allowing a .316 batting average and .533 slugging percentage including eight of his 11 home runs compared to righties allowing a .292 average and .396 slugging percentage.

Tellez only bats .175 at home compared to .287 on the road but he has hit nine of his 16 home runs at home and is slugging .550 in the last 15 days.

Take Tellez to hit his home run prop tonight with odds listed at +350. Other Rangers hitters to consider for a home run prop includes Joc Pederson (+340) and Wyatt Langford (+400).

Enjoyed the Home Run Prop Bets? Get More MLB Bets at the GoldSheet

Play Ball! GoldSheet’s daily MLB betting guide has made its triumphant return. We provide marquee hitter vs pitcher matchup notes, Ralph Michaels‘ NRFI first inning guide and two recommended free plays each day. Oh yeah, we forgot to mention the price…FREE! Use the link below each day to access the download.

WagerTalk Live Odds Screen

WagerTalk’s live odds screen features up-to-the-minute lines from a variety of offshore and domestic sports books. Track moneylines, runlines, totals and betting percentages for a variety of domestic and international leagues. Find free MLB picks, even for Home Run prop bets, and odds!

**************************************************

Looking for more free sports picks and sports betting tips? Go beyond the anytime touchdown scorer picks!

• Latest Betting Odds and Public Action: Vegas lines updated in real time, including who the public is betting on and anytime touchdown scorer odds.
• Last Minute Handicapping Advice: Check out our extensive library of handicapping tips and advice from professional Vegas handicappers (we also recommend taking the time to look over our sports betting tips video library)
• Want an expert opinion? Check out the latest Free Sports Picks and Best Bets from our team of expert sports handicappers.

Make sure to bookmark all the above!